Related
- April 16: A day with special meaning to Tech
- 32 for 32: Community service project to kick off fall semester
- Report says Tech did not provide 'timely warning'
Share
Related:
The revised Panel Report (PDF).
A revised version of the Virginia Tech Governor’s Review Panel report on the April 16, 2007 shootings has been completed and released to families by Gov. Tim Kaine and independent information systems company Tri-Data.
Kaine agreed to revise the report, originally released in late 2007, at the request of victims’ families following the discovery of shooter Seung-Hui Cho’s mental health records at the home of former Cook Counseling Center director Robert Miller in July.
All revisions were completed by Tri-Data. Kaine refused to reconvene the original panel, a measure that many families of the victims called for. Submissions of corrections were also collected from family members.
The revised report, obtained by the Collegiate Times, contains a new introduction explaining the revision process.
“Some families had personal knowledge of the events that were not previously shared,” the introduction to the revised report said. “Some families requested new interpretations of certain findings or revisions to some of the Review Panel’s recommendations in light of the new information. Virginia Tech officials also submitted comments requesting some corrections.”
Unlike the original report, several family members were interviewed
“After completing an initial review of the comments from all parties, Tri-Data submitted a number of questions to Virginia Tech and also interviewed several family members for clarification of their comments, and to cross-check information and corroborate facts,” the report said.
Despite a wide range of changes, the report said there were no corrections that warranted altering the original recommendations.
“The new and additional information has tended to reinforce the Review Panel’s original findings and recommendations,” the report said. “In several instances, emphasis was added to findings where strongly supported by the facts. While some of the findings have been modified slightly and one added, none of the new information merited changes to any of the recommendations in the original Report.”
One major change to the report was the revision of a timeline that many families said was flawed in the original report.
“This Addendum contains an expanded timeline with virtually all of the additions suggested by the families,” the report said.
WEST A.J. SHOOTINGS
The revised report more specifically explains how Cho may have selected and entered West Ambler-Johnston Hall, where he killed Emily Hilscher and Ryan Clark, his first two victims.
“Some students were assigned mailboxes located in a different dorm from their own,” the report said. “They could access their mailbox after 7:30 a.m. Cho was one of these students. He lived in Harper Hall but his mailbox was in West Ambler
Johnston where he committed the first two murders. He had access and reason to be in the mailbox area of WAJ, which may help explain why he chose it. It also was a short walk from his dorm. His motivation for the initial killings still has not been determined. He had no known relationship with Emily Hilscher, nor with her roommate.”
The revised timeline continues to document the discovery of the first two victims.
Ed Spencer, who was then associate vice president for student affairs, was the first member of the university administration aware of the shootings.
An addition to the report said a housekeeping worker in West AJ called a Burruss Hall housekeeping worker, who informed Spencer.
Continue Reading: 1 | 2 | 3 | Next »


Leave a comment 9 Comments Write a letter to the editor
All letters to the editor must include a name, e-mail, daytime phone number and affiliation to Virginia Tech. Affiliation includes: year and major for students; position and department for faculty and staff; current city for alumni and parents.
Connecting the dots is an important thing and there is more that should still be considered. I am personally working on this through my Website {www.vtlessonstolearn.com) and a soon to be published book detailing my ensuing tragedy following the VT Tragedy.
The Virginia Tech Campus and the entire community needs a greater perspective and further healing and until this happens, other tragic incidents are likely. The Cook Counseling Center and Mental Health Community Counselors are needing to learn some things too.
We all continue to seek some closure from the tragedy earlier this year (also personally impacting me) and even finding the killer of Heidi Lynn Childs and David Lee Metzler. Morgan Harrington's disapperance continues to baffle us as well.
The spiritual aspects are still largely being ignored or dismissed, yet are at the core of the emotional and physical tragedies, as well as for each of us individually. May more find healing there and even learn from my own personal tragedy.
Charles Pugh
Campus Minster and Messenger at VT 1995-2007 and beyond
www.vtlessonstolearn.com
Reply to this Top
More information available here in this random article from Wisconsin http://www.channel3000.com/news/21812314/detail.html
Reply to this Top
I am sick of them releasing this stuff and keeping on talking about this if they aren't going to do something in response to these reports. It's like more and more evidence that someone should have been held responsible for not notifying the campus community. I just wish they'd stop talking about it if there's no reason to talk about it.
Reply to this Top
I'm looking forward to hearing what comes out in the civil suit on 12/14. This amended report should help the plainitffs though I would bet much much more has already been discovered by Mr. Hall's team.
Reply to this Top
One policy group member,(Ralph Byers) unnamed by the report, e-mailed a Richmond colleague (Laura Fornash)informing them that one student was dead and another critically injured. The Attoney General's office knew at 8:40am and the only reason this office was informed is because someone in the AG's office was concerned of a neice/nephew that was a student at VT. Does it make sense to inform the AG's office that is over 300 miles away what was going on in WAJ before the VT community. This is a violation of the Clery Act!
Reply to this Top
Thanks for bringing up the spiritual and emotional agony this has brought on everyone with a conscious, Mr. Pugh.
I have questions.
Why did the chief of police at VT get a $40,000 a year raise after shooting?When the state is in a budget crisis.
Why is the Shooting in the gym last August 2008 still being kept secret? And don't give me the privacy garbage. If it was an employee he violated any privacy agreement when he brought a gun and discharged it at VT.
Why are the Admin involved still employed at VT?
VERY scary.
Why does the Admin control the VT police? And why is the VT campus a separate jurisdiction from either the state, county, or town? Which means no other law enforcement can come in unless invited to do so.
Why is Nikki Giovanni still employed at VT? She admits she is on the side of the "Thugs" and not those who are against them. She has a "thug
life" tattoo. She confronted Cho as his professor instead of helping to get him identified and get him help. And no she is profiting off the VT murders and her 10 sec of fame through her increased speaking fees. Why is she still at VT?
Reply to this Top
I can't respond to you first four questions, but I can tell you that Prof Giovanni (and the entire English department for that matter) covered all bases in trying to get Cho some help. She had him removed from her class when he wrote something disturbing aimed at his classmates, and Lucinda Roy took him on as an independent study so that she could encourage him to get some help. Other members of the English department (Bob Hicok, among others) contacted higher administration to encourage them to intervene.
This is the failure of higher admin, not his teachers who pleaded with them to do something.
Reply to this Top
I knew about Ms Roy and I commend her for her actions and efforts and she ought to get the recognition she deserves officially. As she was a lone beacon of light, professionalism, and reason it appears.
However I find Ms. Giovannis behavior and writing disturbing for a State Professor. She was quoted as saying she wasn't going to let Cho "push her around" (verbally) during a meeting with Cho on a sidewalk around campus. Seems she should be able to handle herself a little better with a student in obvious distress and trouble if she is a professional and enlightened professor.
Giovanni discusses her "Thug Life" tattoo, which she sports to honor slain rapper Tupac Shakur. "I'd rather be with the thugs than the people who are complaining about them, for sure," she explains.
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/flash/vd.asp?PID=12012&aud=1&{slinkprefix}&nav=1
Not to mention her profiting from her 10 sec of fame at the remembrance ceremony, through increased speaking fees.
Doesn't fit my description of an Academian.Sorry.
Top
Before commenting on the VT Police Department and their jurisdiction, you ought to better understand the working relationship the PD has with surrounding agencies. You may also want to look a little further into the existing "memorandum of understandings."
Reply to this Top