BYOB sounds like a bargain, but proves costly

Tuesday, January, 24, 2012; 8:59 PM | 8 | | Print

Share


Some Blacksburg restaurants are starting to adopt BYOB — or bring your own bottle — alcohol licenses. In short, customers can enjoy their own wine at restaurants with this license. But there is a catch. Bringing a bottle may break the bank, as corking fees cost more than glasses, and even some bottles, of wine alone. 

For businesses that already serve alcohol, this isn’t a major economic swing, but for those that don’t, it could mean more revenue. However, this is not a necessity in Blacksburg, or more specifically downtown. After all, this is a college town, which comes with more than enough bars — happy hour hot spots that, thanks to their own liquor licenses, do not charge customers for bottle opening.

But what do BYOB licenses mean to the average customer in a college town? Most patrons in Blacksburg are obviously college-aged students, who are living on limited budgets and are typically not wine connoisseurs.

Corking fees at restaurants with this license cost $11 at the least. And since most college students don’t spend more than $15 on a bottle of wine, many are left wondering whether the fees are worth the price. On average, it seems that patrons would spend more than $20 just to bring their own wine to a restaurant and have it “professionally” opened. 

Sure, this license serves as a handy substitute for a restaurant that cannot pay for a full liquor license. But what is in it for the customers? Why not just drink after dinner and open your own bottle of wine for free? Let’s face it, you’re probably going to regardless of whether you drink at a restaurant. 

For those who can afford an incredible bottle of wine — that also comes with an equally incredible price tag — and want to bring it to a restaurant, the corking fee is seemingly insignificant. But there aren’t many people frequenting the restaurants of downtown Blacksburg who have the means or the desire to do this. That is, unless we count John Boyer.  

BYOB licenses won’t negatively affect businesses in Blacksburg, but they probably won’t bring in enough new revenue to make them worthwhile. Instead, college students will continue to drink their cheap-ish wine at home, minus the corking fees. 

A version of this article appeared in the Jan 25 issue of the Collegiate Times.

Leave a comment 8 Comments Write a letter to the editor

Anonymous | # January 25, 2012 @ 8:02 AM — Flag Comment

No, the corking fee certainly isn't going to give you another cheap way to drink. Your editorial leaves me wondering if you've ever looked at a wine list, or taken economics. A bottle at a decent restaurant typically starts at $30, but the same bottle can likely be found for $15 or less retail. For the minority who live here year round and are likely to look for a wine list instead of the best happy hour special, the corking fee isn't that steep. That minority likely hasn't found too many "incredible" bottles for under $30, either. As for the restaurants, I'd leave it up to the owners to determine whether the service is profitable.

Reply to this Top


Bill | # January 25, 2012 @ 11:27 AM — Flag Comment

Bingo. Really arrogant/misguided editorial.

Reply to this Top


Anonymous | # January 25, 2012 @ 11:39 AM — Flag Comment

Actually there are quite a few incredible wines at that price point. The price of a wine bottle is an indication of hype more than quality.

Reply to this Top


How much is a BYOB license? | # January 25, 2012 @ 6:35 PM — Flag Comment

Also, is there a ladder or ceiling on the corking fee? I see "$11 at least," but no other pricing info.

Reply to this Top


What's your definition of worthwhile? | # January 25, 2012 @ 6:43 PM — Flag Comment

Without posting info on the cost of these licenses, not to mention fee structures beyond "$11 at the least," it's hard for a reader to gauge the amount of money involved for local businesses.

With regards to customers, instead of drinking at home after dinner, as suggested, why not enjoy a nice bottle of wine during dinner with friends & family on special occasions, such as birthdays or graduation?

Reply to this Top


anon | # January 26, 2012 @ 7:56 PM — Flag Comment

we charge 5$ for corking fee. oh well for at least 11$ maybe you should have asked more than one restaurant. or is this another made up ct story ?

Reply to this Top


anon | # January 26, 2012 @ 7:58 PM — Flag Comment

I think you misunderstood the license. Restaurants that already have a wine license may allow patrons to bring in wine. if you don't have an ABC License you can't let folks bring wine in . there is no BYOB license. You need a regular license

Reply to this Top


anon | # January 28, 2012 @ 9:35 AM — Flag Comment

There is no such thing as a byob license. What a horribly researched story !

Reply to this Top